Which 3column template do you prefer?

[akira07]

3 column bar is have 2 different type, which is you prefer?

This one :
Column 1 :For article
Column 2: First sidebar
Column 3 : Second sidebar


Or this one :
Column 1 : left-sidebar
Column 2 (middle part) : article
Column 3 : right sidebar

[Indyan]

I prefer having both the sidebars on the right. That way the main content is visible to someone using it on a smaller monitor (with lower res). Its also makes things for all readers, as you dont have to criss cross the page to find something.

[sarahG]

I'm not a big fan of a column on either side of the content area, so providing it doesn't look cluttered or take over, I'd say the first option with the two sidebars together.

[athlon24]

For me, I'll take both sidebars in the right side. Haven't tried the second option but I think it will work if you will monetize your blog all adsense. I've seen most of adsense friendly blog in that setup.

[navjotjsingh]

Even I would go with the first option of having both sidebars in right side. This gives a proper continuity to both content and sidebar content. Splitting sidebar with content in between disrupts the flow and is a bit turnoff. Having content at one side and sidebar on other is pleasant and more readable.

[Donace]

Left Sidebar has a greater CTR by about 7-8% minimum I have found during my experiments, Though having it on the right produces greater 'readability' and increase time spent on site on average by 30sec as opposed on the left.

Having 2 sidebars as opposed to one always caused mixed reactions...the best effect I have had is on sidebar that splits into two mid way...though each to his own.

[akira07]

@donace
it's interesting to know that you already make experiment and get fact that left-sidebar is greater 7-8% CTR. If this true, then adsense placed at left-side bar is good idea. But seem many people don't know about this :D, but is that is deep experiment? I mean , do you make experimen in any blog (not just one) and compare it with many blog which have sidebar both in the right side? Or it's just convenience?

[Indyan]

The results make sense. CTR increases as visibility is more - you tend to first look at stuff that is at the left, but site engagement decreases with sidebar on the left.

[Donace]

@akira Yes I tired this on 6 different sites and that was the average gain; it almost follows as Indyan has said the 'z' principle...you look to left corner first then header then bottom left and along footer.

Though again as mention it is limited by a minimal reaction then. Its a trade of you have to consider...though experiment yourself over a month or two and see what you get.